--- this piece is simple and elegant but despite the names of the dead I cannot feel the human casualties (philip wood)

--- I find this a fine web art, consistent with the subject, utilising the essence of the medium and lifting it to a new level. Good idea, good execution, good look. Obviously a work of a real web-artist, not an artist who uses web without understanding it. (Blazenko Karesin)

--- From all the memorial presentation s off other artists in the list his digital rendering stands out as such and does not need any comments as a memorial . It is well done for the memory of the victims of 911. (Ansgard Thomson)

--- A powerful piece that won't let you separate the means from the end ? they are linked forever. However, he should lose that introductory page. The work is strong enough to standalone. (Besides which it breaks his very own Rule # 2 for Internet Art. But then--- I guess---what are rules made for but to be broken.) (Tom Scarpino)

--- His background with the text remind me the war. On 9.11 NY City was in war, I was there, I was eyes witness, and I felt IT WAS WAR.(Aniko Gulyas)

--- a chilling tribute to the people and the event, although not interactive, it is a project that lens itself to this media (Joddy Zellen)

--- This work is based on name research in combination with ascii art which reflects an abstract display of the events of 911.(Andreas Troeger)

--- The work reminds us of the lives lost, taking the image of the second plane hitting out of the realm of mass media. Interestingly, the work puts the lives into the realm of the textual, abstracting them in a way.(Brooke A. Knight)

--- though the piece is not necessarily critical in the sense of asking for re-evaluation of the incident, I think that it is formally well developed. It works as art, and that, in the end, is the only thing that can transcend politics to some degree.(Eduardo Navas)

--- good use of the medium by combining ascii-art techniques with animation. names of the victims that make up the buildings is an excellent metaphor for the way we see such events through tv's and newspapers. sometimes we see nothing more than what the media presents us although there is much more hidden meaning inside an event.(Ali Miharbi)

--- media savvy and moving (David Crawford)

--- Temporally and visually this piece functions to illustrate the numerous lives lost on 9.11. As the pages of names of those who died continued to appear, I was prompted to think about the immensity of this loss.(Megan Jacobs)

--- Excellent concept and realization (Christian de Lutz)

--- The 911 memorial is a very expected idea but it is graphically speaking pretty well done.(Maurice Benayoun )

--- Laborious work with a subtle use of color in text. It remembered me some kind of ASCII art.(Fabian Giles)